In a recent Instagram Story, I shared (yet again) the Neutrogena Moisturesmooth Color Stick that I’ve been using nonstop for at least 10 years now (primarily in shades Plum Perfect or Soft Raspberry, FYI). You’re all well aware of the fears I harbor surrounding any potential future discontinuation of this or any of my beauty must-haves. When it comes to the Neutrogena Color Sticks, I may or may not have two dozen of them stashed in a drawer somewhere just in case, the world will never know. But this product (and the legitimate nightmares I have that it’s ever discontinued) did get me thinking about what other products all of you feel this passionate about to the point of paranoia, so I asked on instastories. As always, you delivered your answers in droves. Part of me was overjoyed, and the other part of me panicked that I now have so many more products to hoard. Here are your faves, the official top 15 beauty products that, if discontinued, would devastate everyone.